Why Do People Say ‘Don’t Trust HR’?

The Truth Behind “HR Is Not Your Friend”

Most HR leaders have heard the refrain: Don’t trust HR. HR isn’t your friend. HR only cares about the company. It shows up in exit interviews, on social media, and in everyday employee conversations. And while it’s easy to dismiss as noise, this narrative has staying power—and it impacts how employees view our role before we even enter the room.

As senior HR professionals, we can’t ignore it. Our job is not to convince employees that HR is their friend, but to reset expectations and show what our role actually is: balancing the needs of the business with the needs of the workforce.

Why This Narrative Persists

The perception that HR is supposed to be an employee advocate first comes from mixed signals. HR often introduces itself through benefits, engagement initiatives, or culture programs, things that feel personal and people-centered. When those same employees later experience HR in compliance investigations, performance management, or terminations, the dissonance reinforces the belief that HR is two-faced or aligned only with leadership.

High-level HR leaders need to own that gap. The narrative doesn’t disappear until we communicate consistently and model what HR actually represents: advocacy for both sides, but loyalty to neither.

Positioning HR Correctly

The most effective way to push back on the “HR isn’t your friend” mindset is to position HR as a professional function rather than a personal one. HR isn’t designed to be on one side or the other. It’s designed to uphold the systems that allow both people and the business to succeed.

That starts with being clear about its purpose: HR exists to create the conditions where employees can do their best work, supported by structures that are consistent, fair, and sustainable over time.

Advocacy for employees is real, but it is not unconditional. It must operate within the guardrails of policy, compliance, and business strategy. This means HR will listen, support, and guide employees, but always within the framework of what keeps the organization legally sound and strategically aligned. In the same way, advocacy for the company is also real, but it is not blind.

A credible HR function requires holding leaders accountable to treating people fairly, making decisions that reflect organizational values, and ensuring that short-term choices do not undermine long-term health.

When framed this way, employees can move beyond the oversimplified idea of HR as friend or foe and begin to recognize it as a stabilizing force that protects the system as a whole. HR becomes not just a mediator in moments of conflict but a partner in shaping the environment where people can thrive and where the organization can continue to grow. This dual commitment, to both individuals and the enterprise, allows HR to serve as a steadying presence, ensuring that work remains both productive and humane.

Practical Moves for Senior HR Leaders

If you’re navigating this narrative in your own organization, here are strategies that help shift it:

1. Set expectations early: During onboarding, explain what HR does and doesn’t do. Clarify that HR supports employees by ensuring fair systems and resources—not by guaranteeing outcomes.

2. Be transparent in tough moments: When handling employee relations, don’t position HR as “on your side.” Instead, position HR as the one ensuring the process is followed fairly and consistently for everyone.

3. Hold leaders accountable: Nothing undermines HR faster than allowing managers to bypass policy or act without consequence. Consistency signals credibility.

4. Speak the language of business: Tie HR’s decisions to revenue, growth, risk management, and sustainability. When employees hear HR talk strategy, they begin to understand our role isn’t about picking sides. It’s about keeping the company viable.

5. Normalize dual advocacy: Use everyday communication to reinforce that HR balances both business and employee needs. The more it’s said and demonstrated, the more it becomes the default narrative.

A Different Kind of Trust

Employees may never see HR as a “friend,” and that’s fine. What we should be aiming for instead is trust in our professionalism. Trust that HR will act with consistency. Trust that we will apply policies fairly. Trust that we will advise leaders to balance business goals with human impact.

When senior HR leaders approach the narrative this way, the conversation shifts. HR stops being seen as either ally or adversary, and instead becomes what it was always meant to be: the function that holds the rope tight between the needs of the organization and the needs of its people.

Want to dive deeper? Watch our podcast!